Sunday, March 11, 2007

Daf Yomi - Megillah 32 - Highlights

The Gemora cites a braisa: Rabbi Shimon ben Elozar said that Ezra established that the curses in Vayikra should be read prior to the festival of Shavuos and those mentioned in Devarim should be read prior to Rosh Hashanah.

Abaye and others say that it was Rish Lakish explain: This is in order for the year to end together with its curses.

The Gemora asks: This is understandable regarding Rosh Hashanah, but Shavuos is not a new year?

The Gemora answers: Shavuos is a new year for the fruits as we have learned in a Mishna that we are judged concerning the fruits of the trees on Shavuos and it is therefore appropriate to read the curses prior to Shavuos, so that the year relating to the fruits will end along with the curses. (31b)

Rabbi Shimon ben Elozar states further: If elderly men tell you to destroy and young men tell you to build, you should destroy and not build because the destroying of the elderly is building and the building of the young is actually destroying. The Gemora cites Rechovam, the son of Shlomo as a proof to this (he listened to the advice of the young ones and not the elders – he eventually lost the kingdom because of this). (31b)

The Gemora cites a braisa: Rabbi Meir maintains that the place where the Torah reading concludes on Shabbos morning, that is the place we begin by Shabbos Mincha; the place where we conclude by Mincha is the place we begin on Monday; the place where we conclude on Monday is the place we begin on Thursday; the place where we conclude on Thursday is the place we begin on Shabbos morning. Rabbi Yehudah disagrees: The place where we conclude on Shabbos morning is the place we begin by Mincha, Monday, Thursday and the following Shabbos. The Gemora rules according to Rabbi Yehudah’s opinion. (31b – 32a)

The Gemora cites a braisa: Rabbi Meir maintains that one who is called up to read from the Torah, opens it and looks where he will begin reading. He then rolls the Torah closed and recites the blessing. He then opens the Torah and begins to read from it. Rabbi Yehuda holds that he should open it to see where he will begin reading and recite the blessing without closing it first.

The Gemora provides the reason for Rabbi Meir: One recites the blessing when the Torah is closed in order that people will not think that the blessings are written in the Torah.

Rabbi Yehudah holds that this logic is applicable only to a different halacha. The reader of the Torah should not help the translator because people might think that the translation is written in the Torah but it is well known that the blessings are not written in the Torah. The Gemora rules according to Rabbi Yehudah’s opinion. (32a)

Rabbi Shefatya said in the name of Rabbi Yochanan: One who is rolling a Torah scroll closed should make sure that the seam (that joins one piece of parchment to the other) is positioned in the center of the Torah. (32a)

Rabbi Shefatya also said in the name of Rabbi Yochanan: The most prominent person among the congregants should receive the honor of rolling the Torah scroll closed. It was said in the name of Rabbi Yehoshua ben Levi that the one who rolls the Torah scroll closed receives a reward equal to the reward of all the readers from the Torah. (32a)

Rabbi Shefatya also said in the name of Rabbi Yochanan: One who reads from the Torah without the trop (cantillation) or he recites a Mishna without singing it is regarded as a sin.

Abaye disagrees with this interpretation and he states that it is considered a sin if two Torah scholars reside in one city and do not properly communicate with each other in halachic matters. (32a)

Rabbi Parnach states in the name of Rabbi Yochanan: Whoever holds a Sefer Torah without a covering will be buried bare. The Gemora offers various explanations of this statement. It is not understood why one who holds a Sefer Torah without a covering should be buried without shrouds. The Gemora then suggests that the statement means that the person will be buried without any mitzvos. The Gemora questions the logic behind this, and concludes that the statement means that he will not be buried without that specific mitzvah. Tosfos explains that if he had been studying from the sefer, he does not earn the reward of that study. If he had rolled the sefer Torah with his bare hands, he does not receive the reward of the gelilah (rolling the Sefer Torah). (32a)

It was taught in a braisa: Moshe ordained that we should publicly lecture on the duties of each day. We must lecture on the halachos of Pesach on Pesach, the halachos of Shavuos on Shavuos and the halachos of Sukkos on Sukkos. (32a)

WE SHALL RETURN TO YOU B’NEI HA’IR

AND TRACTATE MEGILLAH IS CONCLUDED

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

I have a question Why in the last rashi instead of KIMU VKIBLU rashi says Kiblu vkimu?

Avromi said...

to strengthen your question, i found in a sefer ohr tzvi that states explicitly that rashi is expressing the words of the megillah and their meaning which is kimu lma'alah b'olam habo mah shekiblu l'matah etc. , so why switch the order?

Anonymous said...

Any answers?

Anonymous said...

I dont understand it but
YGB said...

Anonymous said...
Why in the last rashi in meggilah is the oder flipped from Kimmu viKibblu Kibblu vkimmu

Because that's the right order. Chazal darshen from the order in the Megillah "kimmu mah she'kiblu kvar" because its not in the logical order.