Tuesday, March 27, 2007

Daf Yomi - Moed Katan 16 - UFO's

The Gemora cites proof that a defendant who does not pay attentions to the summons of the Beis din can be excommunicated form the verse in Shoftim [5:23]: Curse Meiroz! Meiroz was excommunicated because he did not listen when Barak and Devorah called on him to battle the Canaanites. According to one version in the Gemora, Meiroz was a star.

I was informed that Rabbi Aryeh Kaplan talks about this Gemora in regards to an alien world. I found this article.

Rabbi Kaplan

ONE OF THE UNIQUE ASPECTS of Judaism is its far-reaching universality. Not only does Judaism provide a lesson for every human being, its teachings extend to the very boundaries of the universe.

It is an axiom of Judaism that the entire universe was created for the sake of man.1 In one place, the Talmud reckons that there are some 1018 stars in the observable universe,2 and explicitly states that they were all created for the sake of man. It goes further to state that all the angels and spiritual worlds also only exist for this purpose.3

Of course, this immediately raises a question that many find quite difficult. How is it possible that man, living on a dust mote called the planet Earth, should be the center of the universe? Our Sages realized the vast number of stars in the universe, and also realized that many of them were many orders of magnitude larger than the Earth.4

Actually, this question was first raised in the eighth Psalm:5

When I behold Your heavens,

The moon and the stars

that You have established;

What is man that You consider him?

Or the son of man that You think of him?

Yet You have made him a little lower than the angels,6

You have crowned him with glory and honor,

You made him master of Your creation,

You placed all under his feet.

It should be quite simple to understand that size and quantity alone are meaningless to an infinite God. There is absolutely no question that the human brain is vastly more complex than the greatest galaxy, and furthermore, that it contains more information then the entire observable inanimate universe. Beyond that, man is endowed with a Divine soul that towers over even the highest angels.7

Although the creation of such a vast universe for the sake of man does not defy logic, we still need to seek out a reason for its necessity. Some sources8 state that by contemplating the greatness of the universe, one can begin to comprehend that of God, and thereby fear Him all the more. However, if we speak of the possibility of extraterrestrial life, we must explore the question somewhat further.

One of the first to discuss the question of extraterrestrial life in general was Rabbi Chasdai Crescas.9 After a lengthy discussion, he comes to the conclusion that there is nothing in Jewish theology to preclude the existence of life on other worlds.

As possible evidence for extraterrestrial life, he then quotes the Talmudic teaching that God flies through 18,000 worlds.10 Since they require His providence, we may assume that they are inhabited.

Of course, this Talmudic quotation is by no means absolute proof, for it may be speaking of spiritual worlds, of which an infinite number were created.11

One could also attempt to support this opinion from the verse (Psalms 145:13), "Your kingdom is a kingdom of all worlds"12 However, here, too, this may be speaking of spiritual universes.

The exact opposite opinion is that of Rabbi Yosef Albo, author of the Ikkarim.13 He states that since the universe was created for the sake of man, no other creature can exist possessing free will. Since any extraterrestrial life would neither have free will nor be able to serve a creature having free will (as terrestrial animals and plants serve a terrestrial man), they would have no reason for existing and therefore be totally superfluous.14

One could bring some support to this second opinion from the Talmudic teaching that every land where it was not decreed for man to live was never subsequently inhabited.15 However, here again, it is not absolute proof, since this may only refer to our planet.16

Between these two extremes, we find the opinion of the Sefer Habris17 who states that extraterrestrial life does exist, but that it does not possess free will. The latter is the exclusive possession of man, for whom the universe was created. The 18,000 worlds mentioned earlier, in his opinion, are inhabited physical worlds.

The proof that he brings for his thesis is most ingenious. In the song of Deborah, we find the verse Judges 5:23), "Cursed is Meroz ... cursed are its inhabitants." in the Talmud"18 we find an opinion, that Meroz is the name of a star. According to this opinion, the fact that Scripture states, "Cursed is Meroz ... cursed are its inhabitants" is clear proof from the words of our Sages for extraterrestrial life.

Of course, even this proof is subject to refutation. For the Zohar19 also follows the opinion that Meroz is a star, yet states that "its inhabitants" refers to its "camp," that is, most probably, to the planets surrounding it. Nevertheless, the simple meaning of the verse seems to support the opinion of the Sefer Habris.

The Sefer Habris goes on to say that we should not expect the creatures of another world to resemble earthly life, any more than sea creatures resemble those of land.

He further states that although extraterrestrial forms of life may possess intelligence, they certainly cannot have freedom of will. The latter is an exclusive attribute of man, to whom was given the Torah and its commandments. He proves the latter thesis on the basis of the above mentioned Talmudic teaching that all the stars in the observable universe were created for the sake of man.

One may ask: if the inhabitants of extraterrestrial worlds, such as Meroz, have no free will, why were they cursed? However, we do find that beings, such as angels, can be punished for wrongdoings even though they do not have free Will.20

However, the basic premise that of all possible species only man has free will, is well supported by the great Kabbalist, Rabbi Moshe Kordevero in his Pardes Rimonim.21 Using tight logical arguments, he demonstrates that there can be only one set of spiritual worlds. Although God would want to maximize the number of recipients of His good, His very unity precludes the existence of more than one such set. Since this set of worlds deals specifically with God's providence toward man because of his free will, this also precludes the existence of another species sharing this quality.

The basic premise of the existence of extraterrestrial life is strongly supported by the Zohar. The Midrash teaches us that there are seven earths.22 Although the Ibn Ezra tries to argue that these refer to the seven continentS,23 the Zohar clearly states that the seven are separated by a firmament and are inhabited.24 Although they are not inhabited by man, they are the domain of intelligent creatures.25

We therefore find the basic thesis of the Sefer Habris supported by a number of clear-cut statements by our Sages. There may even be other forms of intelligent life in the universe, but such life forms do not have free will, and therefore, do not have moral responsibility.

Freedom of will, however, is not at all an observable quantity. Even its existence in man has been hotly debated by the secular philosophers. Indeed, the main proof that man does indeed have free will comes from the fact that God has given him moral responsibility, namely the Torah.26 It is in this sublime, yet unobservable quality, that man is unique.

However, if we assume this to be true, we would return to the basic question of Rabbi Yosef Albo, mentioned earlier: If such creatures never have any utility for man, what is their reason for existence?

We find a most fascinating answer to this question in the Tikunei Zohar.27 Speaking of the verse (Song of Songs 6:8), "Worlds28 without number" the Tikunei Zohar states, "The stars certainly are without number. But each star is called a separate world. These are the worlds without number."

The Tikunei Zohar further states that every Tzaddik (righteous man) will rule over a star, and therefore have a world to himself.29 The 18,000 worlds mentioned above would therefore be that number of stars, presided over by the 18,000 Tzaddikim that are alluded to in the verse (Ezekiel 48:35), "Around Him are eighteen thousand."30 However, these may only refer to those worlds visited daily by the Divine Presence, but there may be innumerable worlds for the lesser Tzaddikim.

We therefore have a most fascinating reason why the stars were created, and why they contain intelligent life. Since an overcrowded Earth will not give the Tzaddikim the breadth they require, each one will be given his own planet, with its entire population to enhance his spiritual growth.

Once we know that the stars and their planets were created as an abode for the Tzaddikim, we might naturally wonder how they will be transported to them. However, the Talmud even provides an answer to this question. Discussing the passage (Isaiah 40:31), "They shall mount up with wings as eagles," the Talmud states that in the Future World, God will grant the Tzaddikim wings to escape the Earth.31 The Zohar goes a step further and states that "God will give them wings to fly through the entire universe."32

In a way, this teaching predicts the event of space travel. But more than that, it provides us with at least one of the reasons why space flight would be inevitable as part of the prelude to the Messianic age. This, of course, could bring us to a general discussion of the role of modern technology in Torah hashkafah (perspective), a lengthy subject in its own right.


1. Bereshis Rabbah 1:6, Koheles Rabbah 1:9, Tanna DeBei Eliahu Rabbah 14; Emunos VeDeyos 4. Cf. Sanhedrin 4:5 (37a).
2. Berachos 32b. The exact number given there is 1.0634 x 1018, very close to the number of stars in the observable universe.

3. Cf. Chagigah 12b, Chulin 91b, Esther Rabbah 7:18.

4. Pesachim 94a, Yad,, Yesodei HaTorah 3:8.

5. Cf. Malbim ad loc., Akedas Yitzchak 5 (43a).

6. Cf. Zohar 1:57b top.

7. Cf. Emunos VeDeyos 4:2, Shaarei Kedushah 3:2. Nefesh HaChaim 1:10.

8. Zohar 1: 1 lb, Reshis Chochmah 1:2; Yad, Yesodei HaTorah 2:2, 4:12@ Cf. habbos 32b, Berachos 57a.

9. Or HaShem 4:2, Rabbi Chasdai Crescas was the mentor of Rabbi Yosef Albo, author of the ikkarim.

10. Avodah Zarah 3b.

11. Cf. Etz Chaim 3:1.

12. Cf. Targum ad I(>c.

13. Quoted in Sefer HaBris 1:3:4.

14. Cf. Emunos VeDeyos 1:1, Kuzari 1:67, Moreli Nevuchim 2:13.

15. Berachos 31 a.

16. Cf. Kol Yehudah on Kuzari 2:20 (34a).

17. 1:3:3.

18. Moed Katan 16a.

19. Zohar 3:269b end.

20. Cf. Bechaya on Genesis 3:6, Exodus 23:21; Sefei Chasidim 530.

21. Pardes Rimonim 2:7. Cf. Shefa Tat 1:3.

22. Vayikra Rabbah 29:9, Shir HaShirim Rabbah 6:19 Avos OeRabbi Nassan 37. Cf. Pirkei DeRabbi Eliezer 18, but see HaGra on Sefer HaYetzirah 4:15 that these refer to spiritual worlds.

23. Ibn Ezra on Gen. 1:2.

24. Zohar 3:10a.

25. Ibid. 1:9b, 1:157a, Pardes Rimonim 6:3. See also Tosafos, Minachos 37a "O Kum." The Chida in his Pesach Eynayim, ad loc., states that since he did not live on this earth, he was exempt from all Mitzvos.

26. Cf. Yad, Tshuvah 3:4.

27. Tikunei Zohar 14b.

28. The Hebrew word here is Almos, young maidens. However, it can also be vocalized as Olamos or worlds.

29. Sli'mos Rabbah 52:3. Cf. Uktzin, end.

30. Succah 45b. Cf. lyun Yaakov (on Eyen Yaakov) Avodah Zarah #5.

31. Sanhedrin 92b.

32. Zohar 1: 1 2b.


Anonymous said...

Your Welcome (I told all the Maggidie Shiurim I know 3 about this one I cant wait for the feedback)

ben said...

musings: 1. they curse a star and it's inhabitants. so now what? what kind of repercussions does that have? 2. a star would probably have an angel, like we find with all of creation. obviously the main focus here is the inhabitants, but that was explained as referring to its planets. 3. how did the stars fight with Sisera? was this unique to this battle or did this occur in every battle that the gentiles had with the Jews?